Play or Film? Which is more effective?

Personally, I prefer the play to the movie. Many of the scenes are out of order and in the wrong setting in the movie and it makes it slightly more difficult to follow the story. When we read in class there is a certain interaction that takes place between us as the characters. We try as best as we can to portray the mood of the character and the tone of thier voice. One problem is that sometimes, we do not always match with the characters intended tone. We apply a different tone that does not fit, which is sometimes confusing. It is not always our fault though because the play direction in some cases is somewhat vague and leaves room for interpretation

Amidst this confusion, I think it is beneficial for us to try and read the text as smoothly as possible. When we read, we analyze in our heads and interpret from that what the meaning is.
There are numerous benefits in reading it in class. We can stop to analyze a body of text and figure out the motives and thought processes for each character. Yes, this is significantly slower than watching the movie and quickly hearing each character speak, but it is also more in depth and true to the original play. Hollywood tries to spruce things up and add unneeded content which did not exist in the play. The same can be said about the lack of content in the movie that is included in the text.

There are misconstrued ideas and scenes that do not have as much impact as the play. One example is the scene where Hamlet stumbles into Ophelia's closet where she is sewing. Hamlet in the movie is portrayed as more calm, unshaking and not as crazy as was described in the play. In the play he was shaking uncontrollably and his sigh was supposed to be one that could kill him. It was toned down in the film which reduced it's overall effectiveness. It also failed to show him finding his way to the door and opening it without looking ahead of him. The scene cuts out as he is walking away from Ophelia. His acting however is completely convincing when he stares at Ophelia as he leaves her.

In many instances, the movie is more effective in displaying the story as a whole. When we read certain sections in class, it seems to be choppy and we tend to get a fragmented view of the story rather than a general picture in our head. The flow of events is more understandable when we read first and then see the scene in the movie. We can then judge whether the movie is true to the text.